I have never actually seen how you use the old fashioned fold and pin diapers, but I've seen how leaky and gross they were... I also know how terrible disposable diapers are for our landfills, and potentially for the babies who wear them. I won't go into it, but here's some info if you're interested: Real Diaper Association - Why choose cloth diapers.
So if leaky diapers were the only option, I would definitely go with disposables, regardless of the drawbacks. But the newer cloth diapers are amazing. They don't leak, they aren't any grosser than disposables, and they come in cute colors.
Noel wrote an email to some of our friends who are thinking about babies, so I'm just going to pull that over for the specifics.
From Dad:
having purchased 3 different types of cloth diapers (bumGenius 4.0, Flip, and Rumparooz) I can say two things:
- for the love of god, get Velcro (aka hook and loop) - the alternative is snaps, which seem like the coolest thing ever, but at 3am, they are are not cool at all.
- go with Flip for space, cost, and laundry efficiency
Flips are easier to wash, they don't take time assembling post wash, and they're cheaper. Two covers per six washable inserts times 3-5 for 6-10 covers and 18-30 inserts, plus an additional however many extra cloth insert packs (of 3) you want. Quantities dependent on how often you want to wash. You reuse the cover until it gets nasty or for a ~day, and just replace the liner every time child makes with the nasty. Think 12 changes a day and 2-3 days between laundry loads.
the upfront cost will significantly offset the cost of disposables for the life of the child, plus disposables are like.. the worst thing ever.
to wash:
- full cycle wash once on cold, no soap.
- full cycle wash once on hot, with cloth diaper friendly soap (we use "planet" detergent for everything.. our stuff and daughter's). there are other detergents for cloth diapers (no ingredients that might disable their waterproof awesomeness)
- no fabric softener
- extra rinse to get all the soap out
- dry on lowest heat setting until dry, the covers dry super fast... if you have a clothes line and feel like following the manufacturer's instructions, use the line
diaper rash:
most diaper rash creams (Boudreaux's for the win) shouldn't be used in direct contact with the liners... because I don't know why, but it shouldn't (for one it stains them... ew). When necessary, we've been slathering the child and then putting a reusable flannel baby wipe between child butt and diaper liner.
So there you go... advice from Dad.
Just to throw my two cents in...
I'll speak up for the BumGenius 4.0 and the Rumparooz one size pocket diapers. They cost more and need to be stuffed after laundry, but they go on fast and look just like a disposable diaper to outsiders (like fumbling family members, teenaged babysitters, and reluctant daycare providers). The absorbent stuffing goes in an interior pocket, so it just looks like a single puffy thing. Once it's stuffed and put away, you grab it, slap it on the kid, and go. With Flips, you grab the cover, lay the insert on it, and put it on. There's still no folding or anything, but it's an extra step.
![]() |
| Rumparooz one-size pocket diaper - looks and goes on just like a disposable (except go for velcro - much better) |
![]() |
| A Flip insert and cover system. An extra step, but way more cost efficient. |
I'd recommended Flips like Noel said, but I'd also add 6 or 8 BumGenius 4.0 one-size pockets for convenience and to save the time explaining how "new" cloth diapers work to other caretakers. Here's a pic of the first set of BumGenius we bought. We now have lots of pink and purple diapers as well.
I also recommend a few washable pail liners and a zippered wet bag or two. We have PlanetWise Pail liners and Kanga Care's wet bag.
Oh and a note about laundry - exclusively breastfed poop totally dissolves in water. It's completely gone from the wash water after the first fill and drain cycle. Once we start solids, we'll use flushable liners that will collect the poop so that we can flush it away.
So yeah, we are loving our cloth diapers. The extra laundry isn't terrible, and not having to buy diapers constantly is great. Plus fewer non-biodegradable diapers in landfills is always a good thing.






